Let Me Tell you What I Liked About: Evita

Welcome to a new series I call “Let Me Tell You What I Like About…”    The premise is basic.  I am going to write about the things I LIKE about a Broadway show.  I see a lot of shows, and in this era of the snarky armchair critics that haunt the Broadway message boards, a moment of “Hey, you know what I thought was cool” isn’t a bad idea.
On top of that, I want to continue our conversation about the ins and outs of a Broadway show, but this time, talk about a real Broadway show, not just a television show that’s about a Broadway show.  Are you all with me?  Instead of doing fact or fiction, we’re doing:

Let Me Tell You What I Liked About….


Let’s start with a quick history of Evita to catch up those of you who might not eat, sleep and breathe musical theater history the way some people do–and by “some people” I mean my husband Rob Meffe, who just so happens to be a professor of musical theater history and repertoire for Pace University’s musical theater program.

Rob says I always drag him into my projects (in fact, as I type this sentence he is recording music for a show I am directing), so let this series not be an exception to that rule.

And now, direct from the piano, Mr. Rob Meffe.

The original Broadway production of Evita opened in 1979, the same year that Sweeney Todd opened (I bet you didn’t know that Andrew Lloyd Webber and Stephen Sondheim share the same birthday, too; March 22).  It was directed by Hal Prince and starred Mandy Patinkin and Patti LuPone. Interestingly enough, Evita, like the earlier Andrew Lloyd Webber/Tim Rice hit, Jesus Christ Superstar, was originally recorded as a double album prior to being imagined for the stage.  Andrew Lloyd Webber went into a recording studio with Colm Wilkinson, Julie Covington and the London Philharmonic to record their “rock opera.”  The hit song “Don’t Cry For Me Argentina” was not the original lyric for the tune; originally it read:
It’s only your lover returning
The truth is I never left you
All through my wild days
My mad existence
I kept my promise
Don’t keep your distance
Tim Rice (the lyricist) thought the tune was good, but the hook of the lyric wasn’t memorable.  He threw in the lyric “Don’t cry for me Argentina” in place of the first line as a placeholder (it was a lyric used earlier in the piece) and it ended up being recorded.  The lyric comes from a tribute plaque to Eva Peron in Buenos Aires whose epitaph reads “Don’t cry for me Argentina, I remain quite near you.”  The single reached #1 on the UK singles chart selling almost a million copies in England in 1977.

Thank you Professor Meffe.  If you were in his class, following his lecture you would have to perform songs from the era he is currently teaching (this lecture would be a part of “British Mega Musicals”, so you would probably be assigned “Memory” or “On My Own”.  You should hum along as you continue reading).

What I Liked #1:  Opening night.

Okay, look, I won’t beat around the bush here.  My husband was on the music staff during rehearsals of the show, so we were invited to the ritzy, glitzy opening.  Who isn’t going to like that?  It was a free show and free food and drinks.  You had me at hello.  I’ve only attended one other opening night performance on Broadway, and it was for the musical Rosie O’Donnell produced called Taboo.  What do I remember best?  Free make up stations set up by MAC cosmetics, where you could go and “Boy George” yourself (he was the star of the show), or even get your hand entirely covered in thick silver glitter like a glove.  Also, they had a featured drink called a “Taboo-tini”.  I recall lying on the bathroom floor later on that evening.

Evita was a different kind of opening night–not so much cheering (it isn’t that kind of show….I mean…she dies.  Sorry if I spoiled it for you, but also…you might need to brush up on your history a teensy bit if that came as a shocker.).  There wasn’t a signature drink, although there was plenty of alcohol and Argentinian food.  Rob and I walked around and felt somewhere between awkward and part of the crowd.  This is a normal balance if you weren’t heavily involved in the creating of the show.

What I Liked #2:  Buenos Aires (not the city, I’ve never been there, but the musical number.)

Allow me to explain.

First of all I should have a giant chip on my shoulder about this number because Rob Ashford was the choreographer, and it was hard and I know that first hand because I had a final callback for this show and was eliminated because I couldn’t dance it. True story.  So you know it had to be good to win me over, and it was.  Especially good and pretty unusual as far as Eva Perons go, Elena Roger is a dancing dream, and those boys whip her around the stage like she is about to be crowned Miss Dance Buenos Aires.  It is thrilling.  And it isn’t just her.  Everyone dances, including (and I love this so much) George Lee Andrews, who at 68-years-young is keeping up and giving you some acting as he dances.  You might recognize George’s name because he is (fun fact) the Guiness World Record Holder for the most performances in the same Broadway show for his 23 year long run in The Phantom of the Opera.  In August, George was replaced in Phantom (fun fact: by his son-in law.  No, I’m not kidding) and then defied odds by turning around and immediately being cast in Evita (which was originally directed by Hal Prince–the very same guy who directed Phantom.  For the record, Mr. Prince fought hard to keep George in Phantom, but as happens, producers sometimes override even Hal Prince.  Mr. Prince is not the director of the new Evita–Michael Grandage is, but still–I love how small the business is.)  So the point is this:  if you go see Evita look for George Lee Andrews and be impressed.  That dancing isn’t easy (says the woman who couldn’t do it).

What I Liked #3:  The relationship between Evita and Juan Peron.

I’ve done Evita twice, and seen it numerous times, and I’ve got to tell you, the relationship between the Perons is very special in this production.  I’ve always thought of it as a marriage of convenience–a ploy to get to politically hungry people farther, but as played by the intense and incredible Michael Cerveris and Elena Roger, this production of Evita  was a love story, and I liked it.  Notice how Michael smells Elana’s neck when he puts a new necklace on her.  Watch how they touch even as they conspire.  Terrific.  I also liked the marriage ceremony during “A New Argentina”, effective in reminding you that love or no love, this marriage is all about power.

What I liked #4:  Kristen Blodgette

The conductor is a woman, and my friend.  When she was announced at the top of the show, she drew some cheers from the balcony and someone behind me said, “Oh good for her.” Conducting and musical direction is a field thick with men, and that Kristen has stayed in the game for so long and at such a high level is a real testament to her talent and her temperament.  As her daughter Emma said at the party, “I was glad they cheered for a woman conductor, but I’m also like, well okay, but Mom has been working for ever.  This shouldn’t seem like such a big deal.”  Exactly.  But still, we will celebrate her.  Let’s also celebrate her kind and patient husband Larry, who gave me the idea for this series at the opening night party.  Cheers, Lars.

What I Liked #5:  The Casa Rosada Scene.

This is the famous “Don’t Cry For Me Argentina” scene, and I have to tell you that if you aren’t playing Eva, this scene is a total snore.  You have to face upstage and sing “PERON, PERON, PERON” about 5,329 times, and then sing “Evita, Evita, Evita.” another 6,392 times….all while facing upstage.  Facing upstage in a show is a whole pain in and of itself beause you tend to get a lot of notes about “back acting”….meaning that you have to look engaged in the scene even from the back.  I’m not kidding.  I’ll come over and give you lessons–I am a master after all the productions of Evita and Les Miserables I’ve done (Les Miz’s back acting is for most of the second act and happens on the barricade.)

Wow.  That was a lot of negative, and here I am trying to tell you what I liked.  This is harder than it seems!  Okay–what I LIKED about THIS Casa Rosada scene.  First of all–let’s get it out of the way–her dress is to die for.  Second of all, the balcony comes out as she starts to sing (the set is beautiful).  As my friend Jacob said, “When that balcony came out I thought, that’s Broadway, kids.”  Third of all, listen to how she sings the following line (don’t kill me, I am doing this from memory, so I will probably get punctuation wrong):

“And as for fortune, and as for fame.  I never invited them in.  Though it seemed to the world they were all I desired.  They are illusions.  They are not the solutions they promised to be.  The answers were here all the time.  I love you and hope you love me….”

Generally speaking in the numerous productions I’ve seen and been a part of, the Eva backs off of this lyric and sings it apologetically.  There is a note in the score that says something like “Eva breaks down in tears” at the end of it.  I think most women choose to start the manipulation of the crowd at the top of this lyric, but Ms. Rogers sang it with such conviction and so u-apologetically–she was simply stating a fact–that she drew me right in.  As an actress there is nothing better than knowing s show like the back of your hand, thinking to yourself, there is NO WAY that anyone could surprise me with a new line reading.  I’ve seen them all.  And then it happens.  It’s a thrill.  There were many of these moments in the show and so, more than anything else: what did I like about Evita?  Ms. Roger’s stellar acting choices.

Evita is playing at the Marriot Marquis Theater.  It is the first revival of this show.  Go see it.

(To read another “Let Me Tell You What I Liked About…”  go here)






About Sharon Wheatley

I'm a mother, an actress and a writer. I'm glad you're here.
This entry was posted in Let Me Tell You What I Like About It. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Let Me Tell you What I Liked About: Evita

  1. Babs B says:

    I loved Evita and loved that she can dance. The show is Broadway worthy. I am also enjoying that your blog is coming in before I go to bed the night before it's actual posting day.

  2. Jennifer Rae Beck says:

    Can't wait to see it! Love your writing.

  3. nkirchmar says:

    I want to see this so much. But, I won't be able to get tickets when I come to NYC… so, I will have to be content with Avenue Zoo! :)

    This, along with A chorus Line are my two most favorite musicals and the two I identify with the most. Then Les Miz, Saigon and finally Phantom. Then the long list of the others begins. Anyway, thank you for sharing your pics and this blog. Along with yours and Richard Jay's, I felt like I was a part of the night! xoxo

  4. Nancy Stevens says:

    Thanks Sharon for the new series! We are looking forward to our annual trip to NYC as soon as Sarah is done at Furman and I appreciate you sharing your knowledge and insider info. (Rob’s too). Good luck with Avenue Zoo! (look forward to seeing it too)

  5. Ray Gabbard says:

    Sharon (said with a French accent), I saw the same production in 2007 at the Adelphi theatre on the west end and the direction was new and more organic then any past Evita productions. My favourite bit was visiting the virtually unknown and extremely talented Matt Rawle ( che) backstage after the show and chatting about his transformation from an unemployed, no name, corporate entertainer to a successful working actor on the west end. He could only smile and confess of his extreme fortune being down to luck and hard work…. However, it did have an Elaine Paige feel about the whole thing. The only thing that I did not like was that the production only lasted a year due to low ticket sales. I hope that this will not be the case for this one and I hope that American marketing and the use of Ricky will put the bums on seats for a bit more time. George and Kristen deserve this. Oh.. Thankfully Matt did not disappear for too long and went straight into ZORRO. Lucky Man. Hey to Roberto and kiss for the rest. Nice blog and keep it coming. Your mate over the pond. Ray Gabbard

  6. Jason Bratton says:

    I LOVED "Buenos Aires," from the moment those doors opened and you could see the people of Buenos Aires bustling back and forth upstage (which, by the way, looks like it extends for DAYS back there, even though it doesn't). And then when that set is revealed!?!? I literally gasped out loud. It's STUNNING. And the lighting design is incredible, as well.

    Just a fun fact about Eva's "Don't Cry For Me, Argentina" gown: It is based on an original Christian Dior gown that the real Eva Peron wore (there are photos of her in it somewhere), and it is covered in over 160,000 hand-sewn Swarovski crystals. Insane, right?? And there are at least TWO (possibly FOUR) of those gowns! One for Ms. Roger, one for the "matinee" Eva, Christina DeCicco, and possibly one for each of the two Eva understudies (including my friend, Jess Patty, who I can't wait to see go on in the role)!

    Anyway…I'm really glad to finally be reading about elements of shows that people actually LIKED. There's a lot of negativity out there on the chat boards and forums – it's good to have a bit of positivity to counterbalance it!

  7. Kristen says:

    You are soooooo kind and generous. A side note; you might recall a time in our lives when Emma begged me to quit Phantom and get a job at McDonalds. She said that this way she could come to the counter, order a hamburger and then see me. (this when I was traveling a lot). Thank god it all turned out and she still knows who her mama is…. and still loves me! Blessings abound. Thankyou again. So kind.

    • sswheatley says:

      You would've done really well at McDonalds, too. You would've been promoted to manager and still worked long hours (but Emma would've gotten free food, so I guess she has a point there.)

  8. Meg says:

    I (unfortunately) haven't seen a performance with a female conductor (again, DC theatre, haven't been to Broadway), but I've seen many performances with Marin Alsop conducting the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra. She is amazing!

Comments are closed.